
I am trying to find a good practical example of Bayes' theorem use in finance. I have a great example in medicine with cancer screening, but I struggle to find something cool in finance. Should be simple enough for undergraduate students, does anyone have any ideas?

"Earth: some bacteria and basic life forms, no sign of intelligent life" (Message from a type III civilization probe sent to the solar system circa 2016) 


nikol


Total Posts: 794 
Joined: Jun 2005 


Risk management problem:
P(account of clientA is in limit breach)*P(history of limit breachesclients defaulted)=>P(clientA is in default)
Trading problem:
P(see uptick)*P(history of upticks  uptrends)=>P(beginning of uptrend)
PS: My mistake. Above should be modified from 'beginning updtrend' to 'uptrend'. Correct is this: P(see uptick)*P(history of upticks  start of uptrends)=>P(we are at beginning of uptrend)



goldorak


Total Posts: 1062 
Joined: Nov 2004 


We are in 2019 and finance folks are still relying on frequentist statistics. That tells a lot about this industry.
Once you actually reverse the way we have been (wrongly) trained to look at things in finance, and consider the probability of the hypothesis you make given the data you observe rather than the probability of the data given the hypothesis you make, the use of Baye's theorem is pretty straightforward.

If you are not living on the edge you are taking up too much space. 


bullero


Total Posts: 57 
Joined: Feb 2018 


Parameter estimation?
Edit: For example in stat arb you could sample the posterior joint distribution for a set of interesting parameters that describe the stochastic behavior of a spread you are trading. Then, given the joint density you compute the expected pnl. 


AB12358


Total Posts: 63 
Joined: Apr 2014 

 

@goldorak, we have:
P(HD)=P(DH)*P(H)/P(D)
So in order to get the probability of the hypothesis (H) given the data (D), we need unconditional probabilities of the data and hypothesis... How do we go about those?
I know you are super clever, please explain like I am 12 years old. 
"Earth: some bacteria and basic life forms, no sign of intelligent life" (Message from a type III civilization probe sent to the solar system circa 2016) 

Maggette


Total Posts: 1156 
Joined: Jun 2007 


Sorry, I guess I am missing something here. I don't get the question. You are aware of the classical Bayesian inference stuff (start with a prior for the parameters ...posterion = prior * likelihood..etc)?
In general you don't do that in a closed form pen and paper way....
Edit: I get know that I misunderstood the question. I guess you are looking for a more direct application of the theorem, other than general bayesian statistics 
Ich kam hierher und sah dich und deine Leute lächeln,
und sagte mir: Maggette, scheiss auf den small talk,
lass lieber deine Fäuste sprechen...



nikol


Total Posts: 794 
Joined: Jun 2005 


@NeroTulip
>> P(HD)=P(DH)*P(H)/P(D)
Usually P(D) = 1.
>> I know you are super clever, please explain like I am 12 years old.
Hm... Assume that you already explained the concept of probability.
Imagine walking in the museum and seeing Kandinsky's Composition no.XI https://www.wassilykandinsky.org/YellowRedBlue.jsp
Data is painting H is everything what tells imagination about the picture. P(H) is a probability that particular H (let say face) will appear among anything else. P(DH) is a number (EDIT: better fraction=P(DH)/P(D)) of paintings with faces on it. Portraits included.
Then P(HD) is a probability that what I see is face indeed.


